Intelligence – Artificial or Real
There is increasing media coverage about the pros and cons of artificial intelligence (AI). How useful it has become and how dangerous it could be. Certainly, it has dramatically changed the practice of medicine in some specialties. AI is excellent at analysing X rays and CT scans. However, intelligence has many forms and whilst robots are proving to be very good at some of them, recent evidence is showing they are a long way from fully replacing the human interactions of the doctor – patient relationship.
At Wyndham House some of our GPs have been using an AI transcription tool for nearly two years. Consultations are recorded and when finished a structured record is produced that can be copied and pasted into the patient’s notes. None of this information leaves the surgery. It is simply a quicker way of us making a record of the consultation; the equivalent of having a stenographer sitting in with us. A consultation often starts with multiple symptoms alongside other requests for actions. Within 10 minutes we will cover a lot of areas and this often happens with cross overs and jumps in the conversation. The AI tool recognises patterns of symptoms and diagnoses that are linked. It is therefore able to record all the information very clearly. The GPs all agree that its biggest advantage, alongside the time it saves, is that it prevents us forgetting a request that happens at the beginning of the consultation before we delve into the main reasons for the patient coming. We also all agree on the biggest disadvantage of recording our notes in this way; several weeks later we remember the consultation much more clearly if we wrote everything ourselves without any AI assistance.
This difference in recall of consultations has recently been explored by researchers examining AI use in medicine. It is very common and is the reason why lots of GPs have trialled transcription tools but then returned to their previous way of working. The research also posed the question as to whether these AI tools could ultimately make diagnoses without a GP present. The answer is Yes, they could, but only using the information gathered from what it hears. They lack the vital visual nuanced element of communication.
Recently I have been on visits where my diagnosis and advice by the patient’s bedside have been checked by relatives in the adjoining room using AI. As with all medical decisions there is rarely a definitive answer. My role is often to explain the pros and cons of the different options. Continuity of care, seeing the same GP over many years, is known to be advantageous for doctors and patients. Both gain a true understanding of each other’s character and this has a major influence on health outcomes. AI can list differential diagnoses, it can explain the pros and cons of related actions, and it is making steps to acquire the emotional intelligence required to communicate them. However, I think it will be a very long time before the full complexities of the doctor-patient relationship can be completely replaced by AI. Sharing a decision about a hospital admission in someone’s bedroom is a very real interaction for all those involved.
Anthony O’Brien
Wyndham House Surgery


